Black Friday Fleet Upgrade Event15% Off for 3 Months + 24h Data ImportAutomate dispatch, simplify PODs, and get paid faster.Ends in

Trucking Today

Saturday, November 21, 2026

Driver pay per mile vs percentage vs hourly: what each really costs you

We ran one truck through a strong week and a slow week on all three pay plans. The slow-week gap is bigger than most owners expect.

By Trucking Today Staff

Published November 11, 2026 · 8 min read

Driver pay per mile vs percentage vs hourly: what each really costs you

Key points

  • In our slow-week example, hourly pay cost $1.10 a mile versus 65 cents per mile and 59 cents on percentage.
  • Percentage pay keeps driver cost a fixed share of revenue, but drivers absorb rate drops and will want to see rate cons.
  • Canadian highway drivers earn 1.5x overtime after 60 hours a week, even when paid by the mile, trip or percentage.
  • U.S. interstate drivers are usually exempt from federal overtime, but every workweek must still clear minimum wage.

Per-mile pay gives you the most predictable cost, percentage pay moves up and down with freight rates, and hourly pay costs the most when trucks sit. In a strong week, all three land within about $110 of each other. In a slow week with short miles and long waits, hourly can cost you close to double what the other two do, and that gap is what decides which plan fits your fleet.

Driver pay is your biggest line item. According to the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI), the average cost to run a truck hit a record $2.336 a mile in 2025. Driver wages alone averaged 81.8 cents a mile, plus 21 cents for benefits. That's more than $1 of every mile you run. Pick the pay plan carefully and you control that dollar. Pick it by habit and it controls you.

Same truck, two weeks, three pay plans

Here's a simple example. One company driver, one truck, two very different weeks. These are example rates to show the math, not industry averages.

  • Strong week: 2,600 miles, $6,500 linehaul (about $2.50 a mile), 60 hours on duty.
  • Slow week: 1,500 miles, $3,300 linehaul (about $2.20 a mile), 55 hours on duty. Lots of short runs and dock waits.
  • Pay plans: 65 cents a mile, 27% of linehaul, or $30 an hour.

We kept hours at 60 or below so overtime doesn't muddy the numbers. We'll get to overtime below.

Pay planStrong week paySlow week paySlow week cost per mileDriver's slow week hourlyWho carries the risk
65¢ per mile$1,690$975$0.65$17.73Driver carries waiting time; you carry rate drops
27% of linehaul$1,755$891$0.59$16.20Driver shares rate drops and waiting time
$30 per hour$1,800$1,650$1.10$30.00You carry slow weeks, waiting time and rate drops

Look at the slow week. On hourly pay, driver cost jumped to half of that week's linehaul. On percentage, it stayed at 27%, right where you set it. On per mile, it rose to about 30% because rates fell but your per-mile cost didn't.

Now look at the driver's side. On per mile or percentage, your driver made around $16 to $18 an hour that week. That's legal in most places, but it's the kind of week that makes a good driver start checking job boards.

Per-mile pay: easy to quote, easy to explain

Per mile is the classic way to pay over-the-road drivers, and it's popular for good reasons. Your driver cost is the same for every mile, so you can plug it straight into your cost per mile and know your floor before you book a load. If you haven't built that number yet, our guide on how to calculate cost per mile walks through it.

Where it works: long-haul and regional lanes where the truck keeps moving. Drivers like it because more miles means more money, and they can check the math themselves.

Where it bites:

  • Waiting time. A driver stuck six hours at a shipper earns nothing on a pure per-mile plan. Fix this with detention pay, stop pay and layover pay.
  • Which miles count. Spell out whether you pay on dispatched miles from a mileage guide, practical route miles, or actual GPS miles. If a lane really runs 1,050 miles and you pay on 1,000, your driver notices on every trip.
  • Rate drops. When spot rates fall, your per-mile driver cost stays put. Your margin takes the hit, not the driver's paycheque.

Percentage pay: you and your driver ride the market together

With percentage pay, the driver earns a share of what the load pays. Published driver pay guides commonly put company drivers in the 23% to 30% of linehaul range. Leased owner-operators are often paid on percentage too, at a much higher share, since they cover their own truck costs.

Where it works: fleets with strong contract rates, specialized freight, or a lot of short, high-paying loads where per-mile pay would shortchange the driver. Your driver cost stays a fixed slice of revenue, so a soft market can't push driver pay above your target share.

Where it bites:

  • Define the base. "27%" means very different things depending on what it's 27% of. On a $3,000 linehaul with $600 of fuel surcharge, 27% of linehaul is $810. 27% of the total is $972. Write down whether fuel surcharge, detention and lumper money are in or out.
  • Trust. Percentage drivers will want to see what the load paid. If you won't show the rate con, expect questions. If you will, you're set up for a strong, open relationship with your drivers.
  • Bad loads hurt twice. If dispatch books a cheap load to reposition a truck, your driver eats part of that decision. Some fleets add a per-mile minimum so a cheap load never pays the driver below a set floor.

Hourly pay: great for local work, pricey for long haul

Hourly pay is simple and fair. Every hour on duty gets paid, so waiting time, inspections and fueling are all covered. For context, the median U.S. heavy truck driver wage works out to about $27.62 an hour, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (May 2024 data).

Where it works: local and short-haul work, port and rail drayage, yard moves, and any run with lots of stops and waiting. Paying by the mile on a 40-mile day with four stops makes no sense for anyone.

Where it bites: on long-haul, you carry all the slow-week risk. In our example, the slow week cost $1.10 a mile in driver pay alone. You also need clean hours records, and you'll want your dispatch team watching on-duty time so it doesn't creep up without miles behind it.

The overtime and minimum wage rules that change the math

How you pay doesn't let you skip the rules. Here's what applies as of November 2026. Always check your own state or province.

United States. Most interstate drivers under DOT hours-of-service rules are exempt from federal overtime under the FLSA motor carrier exemption. The U.S. Department of Labor explains who qualifies in Fact Sheet #19, including a small-vehicle exception for lighter trucks. Minimum wage is different. There's no trucking exemption, so your driver's total pay for the week divided by hours worked must clear the minimum wage. Some states go further. California, for example, requires piece-rate workers (per-mile pay generally counts) to be paid separately for rest breaks and nonproductive time under Labor Code section 226.2.

Canada, federal. If your drivers cross provincial or international borders, they usually fall under the Canada Labour Code. According to Employment and Social Development Canada, highway drivers earn 1.5x overtime after 60 hours a week. City drivers hit overtime after 9 hours a day or 45 a week.

Ontario. Provincially regulated highway transport drivers earn overtime after 60 hours a week, counting only the hours they're directly responsible for the truck. Local cartage drivers hit overtime after 50.

British Columbia. Provincially regulated long-haul drivers (usually beyond 160 km of the home terminal) earn time-and-a-half after 60 hours a week. Short-haul drivers hit overtime after 9 hours a day or 45 a week. B.C. is clear that drivers paid by trip rate, commission or other incentive still get overtime.

That last point matters for every Canadian fleet. A per-mile or percentage driver who works 70 hours still has 10 overtime hours. To work out the overtime rate, you need accurate hours records, which your ELD logs already give you.

What most growing fleets end up doing

Almost nobody runs a pure plan once they pass 10 trucks. The most common setup is a base plan plus extras that fix its weak spots:

  1. Per mile plus accessorials. Per-mile base, plus stop pay, detention after a set number of hours, layover pay and breakdown pay. If you're already billing customers for detention, pass part of it to the driver. Our guide to getting paid for detention time covers the billing side.
  2. Percentage with a floor. Percentage of linehaul, with a per-mile or weekly minimum so a cheap repositioning load doesn't sink the driver's week.
  3. Hourly for local, per mile for highway. Your city and drayage drivers on hourly, your long-haul team on miles. It's fair to each kind of work.
  4. Weekly guarantee. A minimum weekly amount for drivers who stay available. This is a strong retention tool when freight is soft.

Why driver pay gets messy past 10 trucks

At three trucks, you can run settlements on a spreadsheet on Sunday night. At 15 trucks, you may have per-mile drivers, two percentage drivers, a local hourly driver and a few leased owner-operators. Each one has different extras, advances, fuel deductions and escrow. One wrong mileage source or a missed detention line and you're fixing paycheques, not booking freight.

The fix is to tie pay to the load record itself. When the rate con, miles, stops and detention live on the load, the settlement can build itself from data you already entered. TorqueAI's trucking payroll software works this way: dispatch, billing and driver pay flow from one entry, whichever pay plan each driver is on.

It also helps you see what each plan really costs. When driver pay sits next to revenue, fuel and miles on every load, you can spot which lanes and drivers make money. That's how you know your profit per load before you book it, instead of finding out at year end.

How to pick the right plan for your fleet

Run your own numbers before you switch anything:

  1. Pull 8 to 12 weeks of real data for a few trucks: miles, linehaul, fuel surcharge, on-duty hours and waiting time.
  2. Price every week three ways. Per mile, percentage and hourly, just like the table above.
  3. Check the slow weeks. Look at your cost per mile and the driver's effective hourly pay. If either looks ugly, add a floor or accessorial pay.
  4. Check the rules. Confirm overtime and minimum wage for each driver's jurisdiction.
  5. Write it down. Put the pay plan, the mileage source, what the percentage is based on and every extra in a one-page pay sheet each driver signs.

Get this right and your drivers know exactly what they'll earn, and you know exactly what each mile costs. That's a great place to grow from.

Questions readers ask

Is it better to pay truck drivers per mile or by percentage?+

Per mile gives you a fixed, predictable cost for every mile your truck runs, which makes quoting easier. Percentage pay ties driver cost to what the load pays, so it shrinks when rates drop and grows when they rise. Many growing fleets use per mile for company drivers and percentage for leased owner-operators, plus extra pay for stops and waiting time.

What percentage of the load do truck drivers usually get?+

Company drivers on percentage pay commonly earn somewhere around 23% to 30% of linehaul, according to published driver pay guides. Always spell out whether the percentage is on linehaul only or includes fuel surcharge and accessorials, because that changes the paycheque a lot.

Do truck drivers paid by the mile get overtime?+

In Canada, yes. Federally regulated highway drivers and provincial long-haul drivers in Ontario and B.C. earn 1.5x overtime after 60 hours a week, no matter how they're paid. In the U.S., most interstate drivers are exempt from federal overtime under the FLSA motor carrier exemption, but state rules can add requirements.

Can you legally pay a truck driver by the mile?+

Yes, in both the U.S. and Canada. The catch is that total pay for the week, divided by hours worked, must still meet minimum wage. Long waits at docks and short-mile weeks are where per-mile and percentage plans can fall below it.

How much does a company truck driver cost per mile?+

ATRI's latest cost study found carriers spent an average of 81.8 cents a mile on driver wages and 21 cents on benefits in 2025, about $1.03 a mile in total. Your own number depends on your pay plan, lanes and how many hours your trucks sit.

More from Trucking Today