Profit per load: how to know a load's real profit before you book it
A high rate per mile can still lose money. Here's how to price fuel, deadhead and truck days in two minutes, before you say yes.

Key points
- Profit per load = rate plus accessorials, minus fuel, driver pay, wear, tolls, fees and fixed cost for every day used.
- ATRI's 2025 average was $2.336 a mile with fuel at 48.2 cents. At $6.13 diesel and 6.5 mpg, fuel is 94 cents.
- Divide the rate by all miles, deadhead included. A $3.55 load can earn less than a $3.44 load.
- Set a walk-away number: your break-even rate plus a minimum profit you won't go below.
You know a load's real profit when you subtract every cost it creates, not just the obvious ones. Take the full rate, then subtract fuel for all miles (empty ones too), driver pay, wear on the truck, tolls, fees, and your fixed cost for each day the load ties up the truck. If what's left beats your minimum, book it. If not, counter or pass.
That sounds like a lot of math for a quick phone call with a broker. It isn't, once you have your numbers ready. Here's how to build a two-minute check you can run on any load.
Why the posted rate per mile can fool you
Load boards and brokers show rate per loaded mile. Your truck doesn't care if it's loaded. It burns fuel, wears tires and pays the driver on every mile, including the drive to the shipper. It also costs you money every day it's out, whether it moves 600 miles or 60.
So a load that looks great on paper can come out thin. Rates are strong right now: DAT reported that the dry van spot rate averaged $3.05 a mile in October 2026, the highest since early 2022. DAT also notes spot rates are "all-in", with no separate fuel surcharge. That last part matters a lot when diesel is high.
Know your own cost first
You can't judge a load without your cost per mile. If you haven't worked it out yet, our guide on how to calculate cost per mile walks through it step by step.
The best public benchmark is ATRI's Operational Costs of Trucking report. ATRI put the average cost to run a truck in 2025 at $2.336 a mile, the highest in the report's history. Without fuel, it was $1.854 a mile. Industry reports on the study break it down further:
- Driver wages: 81.8 cents a mile, plus 21 cents in benefits
- Truck and trailer payments: 40.4 cents
- Repair and maintenance: 21.5 cents
- Insurance: 10.6 cents
- Tires: 5 cents
- Fuel: 48.2 cents
Use those to sanity-check your own numbers, not to replace them. Your truck payment, insurance and driver pay are what count.
Here's the trick that makes load math easy: split your costs into two buckets.
- Per-mile costs go up with every mile: fuel, driver pay (if paid by the mile), repairs and tires.
- Per-day costs run whether the truck moves or not: truck and trailer payments, insurance, permits, phone, ELD, office and your own pay.
Add up a month of per-day costs and divide by the days your truck works. That's your daily fixed cost. Now every load gets charged for the days it uses, which is how short loads that eat a whole day get caught.
Price fuel at this week's diesel, not last year's
ATRI's 48.2 cents a mile for fuel was built on 2025 prices. Diesel has jumped a lot since then. The U.S. average was $6.127 a gallon in the week of November 9, 2026, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration's (EIA) weekly diesel price survey. That's up about 60% from a year earlier.
The fuel formula is simple: diesel price ÷ your mpg = fuel cost per mile.
- At $6.13 and 6.5 mpg, fuel is about 94 cents a mile.
- At $6.13 and 7.5 mpg, it's about 82 cents.
If you scale ATRI's fuel line up to today's diesel, the industry's all-in average moves from about $2.34 to roughly $2.66 a mile. Your old break-even number is probably too low.
Canadian fleets can do the same math in litres: litres per 100 km × kilometres ÷ 100 × price per litre. As of early November 2026, Natural Resources Canada's national diesel average sat around $2.50 a litre.
Prices should come down, but slowly. The EIA's November 2026 Short-Term Energy Outlook expects retail diesel to average $5.03 a gallon in 2027. Update your fuel number every week.
On contract freight, a fuel surcharge covers part of this gap. Our fuel surcharge worked example at $6.13 diesel shows how. On spot loads, there's no surcharge, so the fuel has to fit inside the rate.
The 6-line load check
Run these six lines on every load before you say yes. Think of it as your own rate per mile calculator, built on your truck instead of an average.
- Total miles. Deadhead to pickup plus loaded miles. If the delivery city is a dead zone, add the miles to get back out.
- Fuel. Total miles ÷ mpg × this week's diesel price.
- Driver pay. Use your real pay method: per mile, percentage or hourly. Our breakdown of driver pay per mile vs percentage vs hourly shows how each one changes your cost.
- Wear. Repairs plus tires per mile × total miles.
- Extras. Tolls, scale tickets, lumper fees you won't get back, and your factoring fee if you factor.
- Days. How many days the load ties up the truck × your daily fixed cost.
Add lines 2 to 6. Subtract that from the rate plus any accessorials you're sure to collect. That's your profit per load. Divide it by total miles to get profit per mile, which lets you compare any two loads fairly.
Two loads, one truck: a worked example
Here's how it plays out with example numbers. Same truck, same week. Diesel at $6.13, 6.5 mpg, driver paid 80 cents a mile on all miles, 26.5 cents a mile for repairs and tires, $300 a day in fixed cost, and a 3% factoring fee. Your numbers will be different, so plug in your own.
| Load A | Load B | |
|---|---|---|
| Rate (all-in) | $2,200 | $1,550 |
| Loaded miles | 620 | 450 |
| Deadhead miles | 80 | 20 |
| Posted rate per loaded mile | $3.55 | $3.44 |
| Rate per total mile | $3.14 | $3.30 |
| Fuel | $660 | $443 |
| Driver pay | $560 | $376 |
| Repairs and tires | $186 | $125 |
| Tolls | $40 | $0 |
| Days used × $300 | 2 days = $600 | 1 day = $300 |
| Factoring (3%) | $66 | $47 |
| Profit | $88 | $260 |
| Profit per total mile | 13 cents | 55 cents |
Load A pays more and posts a better rate per mile. But 80 empty miles and a second day on the road eat almost all of it. Load B pays $650 less and still earns about three times the profit, and the truck is free a day sooner for its next load.
This is exactly what a quick glance at the load board misses. A broker quoting $3.55 sounds better than $3.44. The six lines tell you the truth in a couple of minutes.
Read the rate con before you count on the money
The rate confirmation (the broker's written agreement for the load) decides what you'll really collect. Check these before you count them as income:
- Detention. How many free hours, and the hourly rate after that. If you aren't sure you'll collect it, leave it out of the math. Get the free time and rate in writing.
- Lumper fees. Will they be paid back, and what proof do they need?
- Fuel surcharge. On contract freight, make sure it's on the rate con. On spot, assume the rate is all-in.
- Payment terms. Waiting 30 days or more costs you cash, or a factoring fee to get paid sooner.
- Paperwork rules. Some brokers cut pay for late PODs or missing check calls. Know the rules before you accept.
Is this load profitable? Set a walk-away number
The fastest calls are the ones where you already know your floor. Work it out once a week:
Break-even rate = (total cost for the load) ÷ loaded miles.
Then add the minimum profit you want per load or per mile. That's your walk-away number. If the broker can't meet it, counter with your number and the reason ("there's 80 miles of deadhead to get to you"). If they still say no, let it go. A truck sitting for half a day can cost less than a truck running all day for nothing.
You can also do it the other way with a quick rule: your cost per mile ÷ (1 − your deadhead share) gives the lowest rate per loaded mile that keeps you whole. Take ATRI's non-fuel $1.854 plus 94 cents of fuel for a 6.5 mpg truck, about $2.80 a mile. Factor in ATRI's 16.5% deadhead average for non-tank carriers, and you get about $3.35 per loaded mile before any profit. Use your own numbers, but if you've been treating $2.50 as a good rate, it's time to rethink.
From two minutes to ten seconds
The six-line check works on paper or in a spreadsheet. It works even better when your costs are already in one place: fuel card data, driver pay, truck payments and repair bills feeding a live cost per mile for each truck.
That's how TorqueAI handles profit per load: it pulls your real costs together so you can see what a load will earn before you book it, then shows real-time profit by lane, by mile and by truck afterward. Either way, the habit is what matters. Check every load, price fuel at this week's diesel, and charge every load for the days it uses. Do that, and you'll stop guessing and start booking the loads that pay.
Questions readers ask
How do I calculate profit per load in trucking?+
Start with the full rate plus any accessorials like detention or lumper pay. Subtract fuel for every mile (loaded and empty), driver pay, repairs and tires per mile, tolls and factoring fees. Then subtract your fixed cost (truck payment, insurance, overhead) for each day the load ties up the truck. What's left is your real profit.
Is this load profitable if the rate per mile beats my cost per mile?+
Not always. The posted rate per mile only counts loaded miles, while your cost runs on every mile and every day. Divide the rate by total miles, including deadhead, and add the fixed cost for each day the load takes. If it still clears your break-even with room to spare, it's a good load.
How much does fuel cost per mile with diesel over $6 a gallon?+
Divide the diesel price by your truck's miles per gallon. At the U.S. average of $6.13 a gallon in the week of November 9, 2026, a truck getting 6.5 mpg spends about 94 cents a mile on fuel. A truck getting 7.5 mpg spends about 82 cents.
Should I count deadhead miles when I check a load?+
Yes, always. Empty miles burn the same fuel, driver pay and wear as loaded miles, but they don't pay anything. ATRI found non-tank carriers ran 16.5% of their miles empty in 2025, so ignoring deadhead can make a weak load look strong.
What is a good rate per mile for a semi truck right now?+
A good rate is one that beats your own break-even, not an industry average. For context, DAT reported the October 2026 dry van spot rate at $3.05 a mile, all-in. Work out your cost per mile at today's diesel, add your profit target, and use that as your floor.



